This story is from the book “Celebrated Criminal Cases of America” by Thomas Duke. It is a work that is in the public domain and is considered to be the first True Crime book of its type. We are presenting the story here below and then we dive further into the story by doing our …
Mount Vernon, New York, July 20th 1925. It’s just after 2AM. It’s been a long day for Joseph Shumacker who is close to ending his work day. He has spent most of his day on several Trolleys, not because he likes to or anything, but it’s because he works as an Inspector for the Westchester …
Today we are starting a new limited series where we discuss the True Crimes depicted in the book “Celebrated Criminal Cases of America” by Thomas Duke. This will not replace our regular show, it will be released as bonus episodes along with the main show. With that said, Celebrated Criminal Cases of America is a book in the public domain and is widely thought upon as one of the first true crime story books to be published in the US.
Now, here is the fun part… for me at least. I am going to do what I can to research these cases. They range from the mid 1800’s to early 1900’s and I will see what I can find. Did these cases happen as they are told? What was left out of the story? I am eager to find out!
First, the story. From Celebrated Criminal Cases of America” by Thomas Duke here is…
THE MURDER OF GEORGE HILL FOR A WORTHLESS CLUSTER OF IMITATION DIAMONDS.
In 1865 there resided in San Francisco a young man named George Hill, who had inherited a comfortable fortune, which he had almost entirely dissipated in the gambling games. He was a flashy dresser and constantly wore a scarf pin, said to contain a cluster of diamonds valued at $1,500.
Hill had a room in the Mansion House, on Dupont, near Sacramento street, and on February 15, 1865, he disappeared. Being of a somewhat wild and roving disposition, no significance was attached to this, either by his landlady or associates.
Some weeks after his disappearance, a gardener named Mr. McGloin was walking through the sand out near his home in San Souci Valley, which is now better designated as the vicinity of Fulton and Baker streets. A dog he had with him began pulling and tugging at a piece of hay rope, which ap peared to be securely fastened to something buried under the sand.
Curiosity prompted Mr. McGloin to investigate, and to his horror he found that the rope was tied around the badly decomposed body of a man. He immediately informed the police of his discovery and the body was brought into town for identification. There was a hole in the side of the head made by some blunt instrument which had evidently caused his death. All valuables had been removed from the body.
Owing to the advanced state of decomposition, it was very difficult to identify the body and the authorities were about to bury the remains when a newspaper reporter who knew Hill well, identified the body.
The police then proceeded to Hill’s room, and the landlady stated that the day after his disappearance, a young man whom she described accurately had come to her house and stated that Hill was about to go to Contra Costa County to procure some money, but that he had met with an accident.
The stranger produced a shirt which had some blood on it and stated that Hill had instructed him to exchange it for a clean one. He was admitted to Hill’s room and, after putting the bloody shirt in the trunk and removing some other articles, he departed, but returned shortly afterward to regain possession of the shirt. The landlady’s suspicions becoming aroused she refused to admit him to Hill’s room.
One of the officers who heard the landlady describe this man recalled that a man then in custody on a charge of forgery answered that description perfectly. Upon being brought before the landlady he was positively identified as the man she referred to and it was learned that his name was Thomas Byrnes, a butcher by trade and the son of the keeper of a roadhouse near Calvary Cemetery.
Mr. McGloin, who discovered Hill’s body, was a warm friend of the family of the murderer.
It was ascertained that on the evening of February 15, 1865, Hill procured a two-horse buggy from Wright & Roden’s livery stable on Kearny street, near Pine, and in company with Byrnes started for the Cliff House.
About midnight the horses returned alone to the stable, causing the stable-keeper to conclude that there had been a runaway and that the horses had broken away from the vehicle. After a while Byrnes came in and stated that they had met with an accident and that his partner being injured, had sent him for another team.
Before starting away with his second rig, Byrnes asked for a shovel, stating that he wanted to dig the wheels of the other buggy out of the sand. It was observed by the stable man that Byrnes threw a piece of hay-rope into the buggy.
When Hill and Byrnes started the first time, Byrnes in- sisted on taking a monkey-wrench along, stating that it might be needed.
When they arrived at a spot near where the body was found, Brynes crushed Hill’s skull with the monkey-wrench, the end of which fitted into the wound perfectly. He then cut the harness and scared the horses away, to make it appear that Hill met his death in a runaway accident. He reconsidered, however, and decided that the runaway would not account for San Francisco Cases 65 the loss of Hill’s property, so the idea of burying the body came to his mind. The rope was used to drag it into the sand, and of course the shovel was used to dig the grave.
It was afterwards learned that Byrnes attempted to pawn Hill’s jewelry and was greatly chagrined to learn that “diamonds” which he thought were worth nearly two thousand dollars, were in reality worth less than three dollars. Byrnes was found guilty of murder and after a futile appeal to the Supreme Court was executed on September 3, 1866.
From this original story, what I was able to find is a pretty similar story, but there are several things that are left out. First of all, George Hill was actually Charles T. Hill. Not sure why the name was changed, perhaps George was a nickname. Also, this case was far from an easy win. This case was almost purely circumstantial. There were no witnesses to a crime here. Yes there were witnesses to what Byrens movements were before and after the murder, but for the crime itself, no one saw it happen. If you read the newspapers of the time, it’s a really interesting take. You can tell from how it’s written, they are not sure how this will all play out. Several times they mention how circumstantial this case is and then just report the facts of the case.
The other thing that I noticed was that in the book, the diamonds were supposed to be worth around 1500 dollars. But, it was reported at the time they were actually thought to be worth 500 dollars. Now, there is a level of error here that could account for this. The reports at the time could of been wrong, Thomas Duke could have been quoting a inflated price since the story was written years after the murder or he could have inflated their worth to make it more interesting. I don’t know, but I thought it was worth mentioning.
The trial itself was really interesting as well. Byrne seemed sure that he would be found innocent. He was laid back and seemed fine with the proceedings as they happened. This probably didn’t help his case.
Overall, this was written as it happened from what I can tell.
Anyways, I hope you enjoyed this bonus episode. We will have several more come out in the future. If you would like to see what is coming up in future episodes or would like to join in on the fun, join us on our Facebook Page, Okie Investigations. If you haven’t already, please subscribe, so that when we have new episodes, you will be the first to know.
November 3rd, 1948. Robert Taylor started his day like every other during the school year. He got up early in the morning and started up his school bus. Robert was one of the drivers for the local school near Arcadia in 1948. It was a quiet Wednesday morning, he picked up the kids, one by …
When you work in a hospital, you are always preparing for the unknowable. There is always something going on, a crisis can break out at any moment. This is one thing that has always stayed constant for the last 100 years. This was no different in Claremore Oklahoma on December 18th 1937.
A man entered the hospital, carrying a woman who was covered in blood. The doctors and nurses took the woman and began doing what they could for her. She had been shot in the chest and was bleeding out fast.
According to the man they had an argument, she grabbed his gun out of his overcoat and shot herself. He tried to stop her but it was too late.
The staff knew that there was little they could do for this woman, even if they were able to get to her right away, it would be a difficult procedure.
As the woman died on the operating table, the doctor looked at the woman’s face. She had a fresh swollen black eye and a broken nose. When he pointed this out to the nurse they discussed the man’s story and how things don’t seem to quite add up and so they decided to discuss her death with the police. They would have done this anyways, but they wanted to pass on their suspicion.
They called the police station and spoke to Sheriff Tom Dean. The Sheriff agreed that there was something suspicious about the man’s story. He went to the hospital and got the official statement from the woman’s husband. His name was William Stephens. He was 26 years old and employed at the McAlester Prison as a guard. He had gone to go pick up his wife at her sister’s house and they got into an argument. She was very upset about something that was going on and he decided to borrow a car from a friend, George Manifee, to get her quickly. On their way home, they got into an argument. He stated that he pulled over and got out of the car to cool off. He had left his overcoat in the car, when he returned to the car he saw his 22 year old wife, Jewel Stephens, pointing a gun to her chest. He reached through the car window and grabbed the gun, they struggled and the gun went off, she had shot herself. He then quickly drove her to the hospital.
The Sheriff asked William what he and his wife were fighting over and he wouldn’t say.
It was just after midnight, the Sheriff decided that there were too many things not adding up in this case so he arrested William Stephens on the suspicion of murder and booked him into the jail.
The next day. The Sheriff and the County Attorney D. M. Battenfield, decided to meet up and start investigating this case. Now at this time, when someone died and it could have been murder, the County Attorney would like a Corner’s Jury to take place so that they could know for sure what the cause of death was.
If you don’t know, a coroner’s jury is a practice where medical professionals are gathered to do an autopsy. They would each come out their own conclusion and they would then cast their votes on the cause of death. This is a practice that actually dates back to medieval England. It is not done very often anymore but I think that there is some room for bringing it back, especially in high profile cases where someone may have a bias that may affect their findings.
But in this case, there was no need for it. It didn’t take a medical professional to state that the cause of death here was the gunshot wound to the chest.
The Sheriff spoke to Jewel’s parents. She had spent part of the day with them before she decided to walk over to her sisters house. Both of her parents state that her face was fine at the time. She didn’t have a black eye or broken nose.
They then interviewed Jewel’s sister. She stated that Jewel left when William came to pick her up. When she left her house, she was fine, no blackeye or broken nose.
It was shortly after she left her sister’s house, she apparently suffered bruises and broken nose and then shot.
Both the Sheriff and the County Attorney were very careful about this case. William Stephens was a guard at the state prison and case form a family of lawmen. They knew this looked like murder and they wanted to make sure there was no doubt about it when they went to trial.
But when they got back to the station they discovered that William was going to make this as difficult as possible. He refused to talk to authorities so they couldn’t get more details out of him or be able to see if he changed his story over time.
So they did just about the only other thing that they could do, they got him set up for a preliminary hearing where he would make a plea and they could present their evidence.
The hearing was set a few weeks later. With little news coming out about the case, the towns people became afraid that the county was going to do a favor for William and let him walk. So they started a petition and when they gathered a substantial amount of signatures, they sent it to Governor Maryland.
The Governor decided that he was going to step in, the day before the hearing, he appointed a special assistant attorney to take 10 days and take a look at the case. If he sees no red flags, they will reschedule the hearing with the county attorney.
During this time the special attorney took a look at the case. He saw that there was nothing fishy going on and that everyone was treating this like any other case so he turned it back over to the original attorney.
While all of this was going on, the attorney for the defense was trying his best to get the case out of the county. He felt that there was no way to receive a fair trial that was covered so negatively in the local press. But the judge denied the request.
The trial started on March 16th 1938. William plead not guilty to the charges of murder and everything was set to begin. The first thing that the defense did was they brought in the staff at the hospital to set what happened and how Jewel arrived and in what kind of condition.
They also brought in the death car so that they Jury can one by one look it over and see a bullet hole in the passenger seat. This was very impactful to the jury and the defense knew it. The defense filed for a mistrial, stating that the introduction of the car and the inspection of it was going to sway the jury unfairly, the request was denied.
Jewel’s sister then testified that when Jewel left her house, she did not have any bruises or a broken nose.
The defense could see the writing on the wall. There was a lot going against William and the only way they were going to stand a chance was if William himself testified in his defense. It’s his story that he went to pick up his wife from her sister’s house. She wanted to leave her house because she was uncomfortable because her sister was with a bootlegger friend. He stated that they borrowed the car from George Manifee. On their way out of town they got into a fight. He stopped the car and got out for a few minutes. He said when he returned to the car, his wife had found his gun in his overcoat and was pointing at her chest. He tried to wrestle it from her, but she was able to fire it into her chest. He then stated that he then quickly drove to the hospital and she was still in the sitting position, her head fell forward and hit the dash of the car a couple of times while he was driving. That’s how she got the black eye and broken nose.
After his testimony, the case was handed over to the jury. They had the case over night and came back with a verdict the next day. Guilty. The recommended sentence was Life in prison. It was reported that William was relieved he didn’t end up with the death penalty. The judge asked William if he had anything to say. The only thing he asked was he not be placed in McAlester Prison. He worked there and the inmates would kill him.
Four days later the judge sentenced William to life in McAlester Prison. His face went pale when the prison was announced.
William went to prison. Although I could not find any information on him past this time, and believe me I searched, I bet William didn’t have too good of a time in Prison.
So what do you think? Did William kill Jewel? Let us know in the comments below and I will see you all next time.
December 5th 1937, In Pryor Oklahoma. News travels fast though the little towns in Oklahoma. Pryor was no exception, especially when it came to helping your neighbor. That day many of the residents in Pryor were gathering at the Hubbard farm, to search and see if they could find Ralph. You see, earlier that …
Benjamin Sargent is born on March 13th 1896. His Father is Benjamin Terrell Sargent and Mother Martha Cargent
Benjamin Enlisted to enter the World War at Ft. Sill Oklahoma on August 29th 1917 at 21 years old
He was slightly injured in battle on October 15th 1918
He was Honorably Discharged on May 14th 1919
On May 24th 1919 – Six hours after his return to home from France where he served 17 months on the firing line, Carroll Sargent is dead, victim of an assassin’s bullet.
The same day Bethel Kincaid is arrested.
May 27th 1919 – The Preliminary hearing in the trial for Benjamin’s murder starts
Alton Rush is also arrested as an accessory to murder.
September 20th 1919 – There is a verdict in the case.
Benjamin Carrol Sargent was happy to serve his country in the great war. He was a young man from Texas who spent part of his youth in the state of Oklahoma. There, he fell in love with a young woman in a little town called Hochatown. Her name was Marian Woods and they quickly fell in love with one another.
World War One broke out on July 28th 1914. America didn’t enter the war until April 6th 1917. When given the opportunity to serve his country, Benjamin didn’t waver, but he wanted something, or better put, someone to come back to when the fighting was all said and done. So before leaving for Ft. Sill Oklahoma to enlist, he proposed to Marian, he promised that as soon as he would get back from the war, they would get married. She happily agreed.
On August 19th 1917, Benjamin made the trip to Ft. Sill to receive his training. One of the things I did a little research on is how the United States came to train a Military that had never dealt with warfare like this. The United States was not totally prepared and had to decide on how best to train a soldier in their modern times.
During his Training Benjamin became, Private Sargent and in 1918, he was sent overseas to fight on the front lines in France. Later that same year on October 15th 1918, he was injured during battle. We did some digging into his records and found his veteran war record that lists his service during the war. It shows his injury as “Slightly” injured. Which meant that he spent little time away and returned to battle.
One of the things we do know is that he kept regular correspondence with Marian. They exchanged letters when they could, despite uncertainty of the overseas mail at the time, they always seemed able to stay in touch. When Benjamin was not writing Marina he was talking about her. Many of his brothers in arms knew about his girl back in Oklahoma and how they planned on getting married just as soon as he got home.
The War ended on November 11th 1918, Benjamin would stay overseas until he received the happy news that he was being shipped home on April 26th 1919. Just a few weeks later he was Honorably discharged on May 14th 1919.
A few days later, when he was released from the Army, Benjamin decided that the first place he would go is to see the love of his life. They met up and spent the rest of the day and evening together. They discussed their plans for one another and what their future together would be like.
That evening, Benjamin was going to walk to the place where he was staying. Its not known if Benjamin knew he was being followed, but one thing is for sure. A gunshot rang out into the night and Benjamin, who survived the trenches of World War One, died on American soil.
Local police and County Sheriff Dewitt went to the little town of Hochatown to investigate what actually happened. Benjamin’s body was found on the side of the road, little to no attempt was made to hide it. It was likely that the assailant fired the shot and made a run for it. Many residents at the time would have probably looked out to see what happened or, they would have alerted authorities.
It turned out that there was another suitor who was madly in love with Marian Woods. William Bethel Kincaid who went by Bethel Kincaid, had just become a rejected suitor when Benjamin returned from the war. Although they were working with little to no evidence, the Sheriff believed that Bethel decided that the best way to get Marian back was to eliminate the competition.
When authorities interviewed his parents they found out that Bethel was not home at the time of the shooting. He was out, with a friend that night. That friend was Alton Rush. Alton was then interviewed and he admitted to being with Bethel that night but he admitted nothing else.
Not satisfied with the answers, they decided to arrest Bethel and charge him with the murder and they also arrested Alton on being an accessory to murder.
The case against them was not particularly strong and almost purely circumstantial. The trial was short like a lot of the murder trials of the day. The procession broke down the night’s events, how the two accused were out, in the same town, on the same night, with only each other as an alibi. The defense pointed out that there was no witnesses to the crime, there was no one who saw the two accused as being in the area. They both gave their statements, stuck to their story and no one could say that what they said was not true.
The case was given to the Jury and they returned with a verdict an hour later. Not guilty. Bethel’s parents who were in the courthouse were overjoyed with the outcome.
In case you are wondering, Bethel didn’t end up with Marian. He was married a short time after this to someone else and lived a full and seemingly happy life.
So my question is this. Who killed Benjamin? After the trial there was no more looking into the case because they believed that Bethel and Alton just got away with murder. They had their shot at convicting them for murder and decided to take a circumstantial case to trial knowing that they only had one try at this.
So let’s assume that Bethel and Alton had nothing to do with murder. Who does that leave? Well, lets take a look at the town this all happened in, Hochatown. When you look up Hochatown on the map, the place you are looking at is actually the second town with the name. The original Hochatown is not under a couple hundred feet of water in Broken Bow lake.
But before this town was sent into the depths of water, it was known in its early history as somewhat of a boom town. Logging had become the number one industry in the area and Hochatown was at the center of it all. The little town grew and people from all over came to live there. During prohibition, it was known as Oklahoma’s moonshine capital and in the 1920’s the number and level of crimes steadily went up. So, would some of these unsavory criminals have something to do with Benjamin’s demise? Perhaps while walking down the road, did he see something he wasn’t supposed to?
In my opinion, that would be hard to believe. The murder happened a year before prohibition so we are a little too early to be worrying about moonshiners throughout the area. But anything is possible.
So, what do you think happened to Benjamin? Was he murdered by a rival? Did he see something that he wasn’t supposed to? Or do you have a theory of your own? Comment down below or join us on Facebook to discuss the case further. You can find us at Facebook.com/Okie Investigations.
May 18th 1927, Beggs Oklahoma. A small town nestled near Okmulgee and Tulsa Oklahoma. They were on the paved highway that led through Tulsa. This doesn’t sound like a big deal now, but back then, there were not many paved highways in that area. This meant that more people could come through town with ease and at a better traveling speed. This meant that all kinds of people would be able to visit the little town, even the ones that intended on doing harm.
Beggs had three banks in town, a Farmers National Bank, The First National Bank and The American Bank.
The staff in the Farmers National Bank were expecting a regular day. Just like the other banks in town, the Farmers National Bank helped with keeping money and providing services like loans. They helped out local farmers buy what they needed on credit, be it seeds, tractors, land or livestock. Many people in Beggs Oklahoma were either farmers or closely related to farmers so they all had a real kinship to one another.
Mrs. Campbell was headed into town with her children. She was going to go shopping and get a few items they needed at their house. She parked across the street of the Farmers National bank and she stepped out of her vehicle and put her baby in her arms and then she saw the most curious thing. There was a person standing at the door to the bank, eyeing everything going on just down the street. She then saw, as plain as day through the windows, men with guns drawn, talking to the tellers.
Bank robberies were not unheard of in Beggs. They were isolated and that made them vulnerable. Bandits at the time liked these small town banks because getting in and out was typically easy and if done right, can be a pretty good score.
Mrs. Campbell told her children to wait in the car and with her baby in hand, she walked without haste as to not to raise suspicion, and walked over to the pool hall to let someone know what was going on. She walked inside and inside she found Marshal McAnnally having a conversation with the owner.
It was by luck that she was to run into the Marshal there, he was about to leave for the day. It was his and his wife’s thirty-seventh year anniversary.
When she spotted the Marshal she yelled “Someone is robbing the bank!”
Quickly, the Marshal and the Owner of the pool hall jumped into action. The Marshal stepped outside and faced the bank just as the bandits were loading up into their vehicle. The Marshal wasn’t going to give them a chance to get away. He took aim and opened fire on them, they responded with a hail of gunfire back.
Scared for her children, Mrs. Campbell dashed from the pool hall and ran back towards her vehicle. The Bandits targeted her and she was shot in the neck. With her baby in her arms, she fell to the ground.
The Owner of the Pool hall had only went out to witness what was going on, he was fired at as well. Quickly, he retreated back into his place of business as he did not have a weapon himself.
As the vehicle sped away, he stepped out from cover to continue to fire at the fleeing vehicle. As he stepped out into the street he didn’t notice that, from behind another car was speeding towards him. A man leaned out of the side of the car and aimed a sawed off shotgun at the officer and fired. Marshal McAnnally died instantly.
Three cars in all sped away from the little town. As they did so, they fired wildly into the sides of buildings, breaking windows and causing chaos in their wake.The townspeople were not going to take this lightly. Quickly responding to the shots, they formed a posse, gathered weapons and found a car to pursue them. They drove off into the direction that the bandits went but the only thing that they found was one of their cars, empty. It seemed that they had suffered a flat tire. Either from driving too fast down the bumpy road or one of McAnnally’s shots had done the job. There was also blood in the back of the vehicle. It seemed that they didn’t all get out unscathed.
The News quickly spread that two of the three banks had been robbed at precisely the same time. Both the Farmers National Bank and the First National Bank. There was a third bank, the American National Bank that was not robbed. It was further down the road but, one of the three vehicles that sped away, came from that area as if it too were supposed to be robbed.
Mrs Campbell was rushed to the hospital. She was not expected to live but she was made of stronger stuff and survived the attack.
There was a large multi face clock on a corner and it was theorized that this was how they synchronized the robberies. On one side the two sets of bandits were able to stay synchronized. The other side of the clock ran a few minutes behind. So it was believed that the bandits that were supposed to hit the American National Bank at the same time as the others, but were not synchronized with the others.
A few of the witnesses recognized a man who had been in the Oklahoma and National News almost daily for the past year, Matthew Kimes. Matt was a well known fugitive. Robbing banks, killing whoever got into his way and when he was caught, his men had broken him out of jail. He was one of the hardest outlaws to catch, always seeming to be one step ahead of the marshals. By this time it was almost a joke. If someone lost their keys they would say “I bet the Kimes gang had something to do with this.” or “Was Matt Kimes in town?”
Part of his success was that it seemed like he was always traveling, never staying in one place for too long. There were reported sightings of him all over the place so it seemed like he was everywhere and nowhere all at the same time.
Some of the stories seemed too fantastic to have actually always been Kimes behind the act, but there was a reason that the bankers in Beggs would know who Kimes was. A year before this robbery, Matt Kimes robbed the same Farmers National Bank.
The Manhunt was on but the police had little to go on. Kimes and his gang were masters at hiding and they had little to no leads on where they were heading.
Days would go by without a break in the case. The Oklahoma Bankers Association decided to protect their employees at any cost. They placed a bounty on the gang’s head. This notice was sent to every bank in the state and began with a five hundred dollar bounty. Each bank donated to that bounty and within a couple of days it had swelled to a fifty thousand dollar bounty on the capture of the gang, dead or alive. Some bankers in the state crossed out the word alive believing that if caught alive, he would just escape again.
On May 31st 1927, Officers were able to arrest 6 men connected with the Kimes Gang. Three of which were believe to have been present at the robberies and subsequent murder in Beggs. Two of the men Blackie Wilson and Owen Edwards were arrested after an impressive shootout with officers in Borger Texas. The three known members of the gand that was present in the Beggs robbery were charged with Murder, the other were charged as accomplices.
On June 15th, In Drumright Oklahoma. Mr. and Mrs. Orville Noble had just stopped by a friends house for a quick visit. No sooner than they had walked inside the door, they heard a car engine come to life. When the Noble’s looked back, they saw their car driving away. Mrs. Noble was frantic. Their 2 year old son was asleep in the back seat.
The unknowing kidnapper soon realized that the sleeping child was in the back seat. He pulled the car over into a vacant lot and pulled the still sleeping child out of the car. He was wrapped in a coat and gently placed him on the ground where he would be found. Soon after, a few boys that were playing in the neighborhood found the young boy asleep and brought him to authorities.
The thief was on his own at this time and was keen to get out of town. He was speeding to get out of Drumright, when he saw a roadblock up ahead. Officers were already on to him and were covering all major roads that lead out of town. This Roadblock however, only had one officer watching it. He rolled up slowly and when the officer approached his car, he pulled out his sawed off shotgun and aimed it at the officer. The thief then took the officer down the road and then tied him to a tree.
The Officer said that he thought it was Kimes and he asked. The man admitted his identity and proved it by showing him some photos of himself. What a strange sight it would be to see an officer tied to a tree looking at photos with a known killer. The man then sped off in his stolen Buick roadster.
Another Posse was formed but they were about as lucky as the last. All they found was the stolen vehicle, abandoned in Oilton, Oklahoma just west of Tulsa.
Sensing that things were getting a little too hot in Oklahoma. Matt Kimes quickly plotted his escape from the sooner state. Little did he know, this would be his undoing.
9 days after his flight from capture in Drumright, Kimes was spotted by Forest Rangers at the Grand Canyon National Park. Kimes signed in at the station as Henry Watkins from Oklahoma. The Rangers phoned ahead to local law enforcement and the hotel where he was headed to who was really coming. Kimes parked his car at the Hotel and took a short walk to the rim of the Grand Canyon. Below him was a slope that dropped hundreds of feet.
Local Sheriff J. O. Parsons and Chief Forest Ranger J.P. Brooks arrived and quickly found Kimes who was enjoying the view. The Sheriff approached with his gun drawn. Kimes turned around and saw what was happening. He started to reach for his own gun but quickly realized that he would lose this fight. Quickly and without any warning, Kimes leaped over the rim of the canyon to land in thick brush on a ledge just below the rim of the canyon. If he had missed his target, he would have fallen to his death.
Kimes tried to make a run for it but on foot and in a place that he was not familiar with, he was quickly surrounded. He exchanged fire with the officers and then when he decided that all hope was lost, he willingly gave up.
Sheriff John Russell and two of his deputies drove out to Arizona and retrieved Kimes. They drove him back to the Okmulgee county jail. Almost as soon as he was back in Jail, he was giving interviews about what he states really happened. He would deny all involvement in the killing in Beggs. “It was badly done,” He said. “It was totally unnecessary to kill McAnally. I had nothing to do with it.”
One thing smaller jails had to contend with at the time was when angry mobs would form and then they would break into the jail and drag the prisoner out. Typically, to kill them. But in this case, thousands of people from all around gathered around the jail because they just wanted to get a glimpse of the outlaw. You see. Kimes had become somewhat of a celebrity. His name was mentioned in papers from all over the united states for one thing or another almost every single day.
So, with Kimes approval. They Paraded him around the courthouse square. Kimes was given time to bathe, shave and change his clothes before going out. It was said that he was somewhat taken aback from the response that he received. He spent most of his time on the run and didn’t realize that he had become this celebrity. As he walked around it was reported that he was followed by his wife who showed no emotion and several other women who were all crying. After the first go around, they decided to let him go out again later in the day to be paraded around again.
At the Trial, Kimes pleaded not guilty and the whole show was on its way. Matthew Kimes had a self proclaimed “Cowboy” Lawyer named Sid White. He was a very outspoken and animated character.
First off the prosecution brought forth Sheriff Russell who would go on to testify that they knew that Kimes had a long range pump gun. They found one in his possession in Arizona and Kimes had admitted to the Sheriff that it was his. The gun was presented to the court. Attorney Sid White picked up the gun and looked at it as if he didn’t believe a word they said about it. He fumbled with the gun for a minute and then put it back down.
Kimes gang member Roy “Blackie” Wilson had turned state’s evidence against his fellow gang members for a lighter sentence. He named the members in the group that were involved in the murder and robberies that took place in Beggs. He named Kimes as the leader of the group.
The Prosecution brought in several witnesses who were either in the bank or on the street and saw Matthew Kimes. A woman who was in the bank testified that Kimes spoke to her directly when he saw how frightened she was. He told her “Don’t worry, we are not gonna hurt you.”
The defense brought a Texas doctor to trial who was attending to Kimes’s mother who was very ill and on her deathbed. He stated that on the day of the killing he knew that Kimes was with his mother.
Others testified that they witnessed the crimes happen in Beggs but didn’t see Kimes at all.
It was all handed over to the Jury. This case was unique. Typically a jury has the choice to let someone go by finding them not guilty, or sentence them to jail time or death. But in this case, Kimes was already convinced of a separate crime and had escaped from jail. So they could either find him not guilty to let him serve his life sentence or they could sentence him to death.
It took the jury over 24 hours to reach their decision. In this case, the jury chose death.
When read aloud to the court Kimes seemed unphased. When he was led out of the courthouse the guard said “Well, Matt, you can’t beat me in a game of pitch tonight.” and Matt responded “The hell I can’t. I haven’t anything else to think about now.”
Now, there was apparently some errors that the state made in the first trial that ended up forcing the state to give Kimes another trial. The death penalty was removed from ever being sentence on Kimes. He was retried in September of 1928. Kimes made an agreement with the Prosecution and pleaded guilty to the Murder of Marshal McAnally.
From 1928 to 1945 Kimes would remain behind bars. He was considered a model prisoner. He was popular and somewhat of a celebrity. When the prison would put on baseball games or shows, it would not be uncommon for Kimes to be a feature of it.
In a strange but not all that unexpected turn of events. Kimes was up for parole in 1945. The Judge thought it was a good idea to let Kimes out on a three day pass to present his bid for freedom to the Governor. He was awarded a 6 month leave from his sentence. Not too long after he received his new found freedom, a bank in Morton Texas was robbed. The FBI believed that Kimes was up to his old tricks once again. Kimes died in an automobile accident in Arkansas soon after. Inside the car, police found over a thousand dollars in cash and a pistol.
The Oklahoma parole board was heavily criticized for letting Kimes go.
May 16th 1921, In the little town of Caddo, Oklahoma. Shortly before dark, Lloyd Wideman was just leaving the Baptist Church with a friend. They got into his car and he took his friend home, that was across town. On his way back, he drove down Buffalo and turned south on Manning. A little ways …
Hello everyone and welcome Okie Investigations. My Name is Trevor Shelby. In this episode we are going to discuss the Murder of 19 year old Ruth Harris. She was betrayed by the man who she once wanted to marry. In this episode we will discuss What happened, Why and what’s happened since.
But first, if you are a first time listener, to experience this podcast to its finest, hit that subscribe button so when we have new episodes, you will be the first to know. Then, head on over to our facebook page. Here we can all discuss the case together and perhaps come up with our own theories on the many cases that will be featured on this show. You can find us at Facebook.com/okieinvestigations.
The year is 1926 in Miami OKlahoma. 19 year old Ruth Harris is a boarder who lives with her fiance’s sister, Mrs. Eva Marks. But, Ruth was in a bit of a predicament. You see, she was in love with her current fiance Walter Wigger and also in love with another man, Edward Montee.